BLATANT EXAMPLES OF THE FACT THAT OLIVIA’S MEMORY PROBLEM HAS BEEN THERE EVER SINCE SHE CAME TO THIS TIMELINE
1) Peter glimmered in Jacksonville but their first kiss was in Over There Part 2.
2) Our!Olivia wasn’t in the operahouse, Amber!Livia was so she shouldn’t know about what happened to September.
3) Our!Olivia doesn’t remember the trials. She never did. Amber!Livia on the other hand had memories about it.